Whatever is one to do with the pounds and pounds of candy canes that accumulate from various holiday parties, decorations, and kids' backpacks?
My standard approach is to tuck these trappings of Christmas season into nooks and crannies, into this candy bin or that... and then in, ohsayNOVEMBER of the next year, to tentatively unwrap and taste one, confirming my deep suspicions that said candy cane arsenal is, YES, truly stale.
Well.
When last year's peppermint stash and this year's (oh, let's be frank, I'm not certain whether or not an archeological find from 2010 is included!) had gotten inauspiciously mixed together, I decided it was off to the trash bin for the lot of them.
Or...
Insert *sigh* of indecision.
You see, I hate resorting to throwing out perfectlystale good food.
Hmmmm. There must be some way to repurpose old candy canes...
ICE CREAM!
We have a verifiable ice cream connoisseur visiting us now so it all kind of fit together in my grand plans. This guest isn't just a "this girl likes ice cream a lot." She's more along the lines of she-who-maps-out-establishments, charting every frozen dessert (every!) shoppe worth dining in within the limits of New York City. I think she's covered all the boroughs. She goes to ice cream pairing menus (a full dinner based on ice creams?!?). I kid you not. And she created a Google map of NYC ice cream for sharing. Her recommendations have never done me wrong. (Here's lookin' at you, WCD!)
And what did Ms Ice Cream herself think of mysalvage scrumptious candy cane efforts?
Bonus: no extra sugar is required- the peppermint candy is sweet enough, at least to my taste!
roughly 9 oz coarsely broken stale (or fresh) candy canes, divided into 3 parts
1/8 tsp salt
3 egg yolks
1 1/2 c cream
(1/2tsp peppermint extract, if desired for greater minty-ness)
Heat 2 c milk to nearly simmering. Add roughly 1/3 of the crumbled candy canes and salt. Stir until candy has dissolved, lowering heat to avoid bringing milk to a boil.
Whisk 3 egg yolks together. Temper with splashes of the hot milk, whisking well after each addition until you've added at least 1/2 c of milk. Return milk with yolks to the pot.
Over medium heat, stirring constantly, bring mixture to the thickness that will coat the back of a wooden spoon. You can taste the mix and determine if (based on color or flavor) you'd like to add another third of the crushed candy now (for a pinker ice cream) or instead to reserve and add later (for greater texture variety in the finished product). Remove from heat. Add extract or more crumbled peppermint to taste. Cover and chill the custard until cold (2 hours or overnight).
Churn in ice cream maker per instructions.
Pack into a container, stirring in the final allotment of crushed peppermint. Cure in freezer for at least several hours prior to scooping and serving.
Serve alone, sprinkled with more crushed peppermint, with a drizzle of dark chocolate, or (oh, the glory) packed in between 2 chocolate sugar cookies.
My standard approach is to tuck these trappings of Christmas season into nooks and crannies, into this candy bin or that... and then in, ohsayNOVEMBER of the next year, to tentatively unwrap and taste one, confirming my deep suspicions that said candy cane arsenal is, YES, truly stale.
Well.
When last year's peppermint stash and this year's (oh, let's be frank, I'm not certain whether or not an archeological find from 2010 is included!) had gotten inauspiciously mixed together, I decided it was off to the trash bin for the lot of them.
Or...
Insert *sigh* of indecision.
You see, I hate resorting to throwing out perfectly
Hmmmm. There must be some way to repurpose old candy canes...
ICE CREAM!
We have a verifiable ice cream connoisseur visiting us now so it all kind of fit together in my grand plans. This guest isn't just a "this girl likes ice cream a lot." She's more along the lines of she-who-maps-out-establishments, charting every frozen dessert (every!) shoppe worth dining in within the limits of New York City. I think she's covered all the boroughs. She goes to ice cream pairing menus (a full dinner based on ice creams?!?). I kid you not. And she created a Google map of NYC ice cream for sharing. Her recommendations have never done me wrong. (Here's lookin' at you, WCD!)
And what did Ms Ice Cream herself think of my
(She liked this dessert. A lot.)
Bonus: no extra sugar is required- the peppermint candy is sweet enough, at least to my taste!
Peppermint Ice Cream
makes 1 1/2 quarts
2 c milkroughly 9 oz coarsely broken stale (or fresh) candy canes, divided into 3 parts
1/8 tsp salt
3 egg yolks
1 1/2 c cream
(1/2tsp peppermint extract, if desired for greater minty-ness)
Heat 2 c milk to nearly simmering. Add roughly 1/3 of the crumbled candy canes and salt. Stir until candy has dissolved, lowering heat to avoid bringing milk to a boil.
Whisk 3 egg yolks together. Temper with splashes of the hot milk, whisking well after each addition until you've added at least 1/2 c of milk. Return milk with yolks to the pot.
(note: my custard looks peach in color, largely b/c of the backyard fresh egg's neon orange yolks)
Over medium heat, stirring constantly, bring mixture to the thickness that will coat the back of a wooden spoon. You can taste the mix and determine if (based on color or flavor) you'd like to add another third of the crushed candy now (for a pinker ice cream) or instead to reserve and add later (for greater texture variety in the finished product). Remove from heat. Add extract or more crumbled peppermint to taste. Cover and chill the custard until cold (2 hours or overnight).
Churn in ice cream maker per instructions.
Pack into a container, stirring in the final allotment of crushed peppermint. Cure in freezer for at least several hours prior to scooping and serving.
Serve alone, sprinkled with more crushed peppermint, with a drizzle of dark chocolate, or (oh, the glory) packed in between 2 chocolate sugar cookies.



















